Monday, June 11, 2012

The Brats and Beer Summit


At the time I’m writing this, early Monday afternoon, I’m aware of five politicians who have made public statements that they’re not attending Governor Walker’s “beer and brats summit” tomorrow:  Dane County Democrats Mark Pocan (my representative in the state assembly) and Senator Jon Erpenbach; and Republicans Steve Nass, Andre Jacque, and Chad Weininger.

The Democrats, Pocan and Erpenbach, are making public statements that they don’t see the beer and brats summit as a means to an end; they say it’s more important to have a seat at the table when legislation is being discussed.  Nass made a public statement about not going because he’s mad at the Democrats for saying snotty things over the weekend about Republicans.

Pocan and Erpenbach are, as usual, misguided; Nass is just an a-hole.  No news here.  Green Bay area Republican assemblymen Andre Jacque and Chad Weininger aren’t boycotting like Pocan, Erpenbach, and Nass; both say they made prior commitments to events in their district which they’re honoring.

Erpenbach, of course, was the de facto leader of the “Wisconsin 14”, who decamped for Illinois, putting off the inevitable for a few weeks and getting a lot of media.  Pocan, who is running for U.S. Congress, is apparently sending the message to potential voters that he’ll have nothing to do with Republicans.  Nass hates and is against everything, so, no surprise there.

Pocan and Erpenbach come from the bluest county in the state, and are possibly concerned that the people they listen to would think it traitorous of them to accept an invitation from The Imperial Walker, perhaps not realizing they’re sending a clear message to voters in the other 71 counties of Wisconsin that they’re not going to play ball with Walker, won’t drink his beer, won’t eat his brats, because god forbid, it might be Leinie’s beer from that Republican Leinenkugel family, and Johnsonville brats, from that right-wing sausage operation in Sheboygan County.

In the rest of the world, the part that’s not Dane County, when you get your ass kicked as hard as the Democrats did last week, and the winner invites you to a party in an attempt to say “no hard feelings, let’s turn a new page and work together”, to boycott the party would be seen as the petulant act of a spoiled child.  Even one of the bluest of the blue politicians in Dane County, Dave Cieslewicz, has publicly called for Democrats to be gracious in defeat, to congratulate Governor Walker on his victory, and take him up on his offer to be more inclusive.

At the end of WW2, after the Allies kicked the ass of the Axis powers and the Japanese Empire, the U.S. led the other allied nations in rebuilding Europe and Japan, pouring untold money and manpower into healing the wounds of war and asking in return only for a few hundred acres of land to establish cemeteries to properly honor our troops who gave their lives. (If you have not been to France and seen the Normandy American Cemetery and Memorial, on a bluff overlooking Omaha Beach, put it on your bucket list.)

We’ve strayed a long way from the path in Wisconsin, and obviously have much distance yet to travel in recovery.  Those politicians who are boycotting the beer and brats summit have every right to do so.  But they’ve only made the journey longer.

9 comments:

  1. Well said. Especially the "...he's just an a-hole" part. Just sayin'.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I would be more gracious if it wasn't that Walker isn't paying for anything - you know the brats and beer will be donated by Johnsonville and Miller/Coors, the first a large donor to Walker and the second received a bill supporting them as small craft breweries pay more for delivery of their bills.

    You can say that people need to be humble, but lets be real, it needs to happen in the capital - Walker needs to learn how to communicate and negotiate. He needs to be a leader this way, unfortunately, he has shown that he uses his childhood accomplishments of Eagle Scout (ever check if this is true>) and son of a Preacher as his only examples of being honest.

    We will see where the John Doe Investigation goes and see if those who did not attend, on both sides, were the smart ones.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I dunno, Tim. I think the gov might be making the journey longer by putting off any substantive conversation in favor of a photo-op. Lots of work needs to be done, but GOP has only stepped up steamroller approach since last Tuesday; RW talk radio is now on a one-note "pension reform" message, and GOP legislators plan ultimate tax giveaway in the form of no more corporate tax at all.

    I think the governor should have rolled up his sleeves last week instead of taking a TV talk show victory lap. If he had, Tuesday's soiree could have celebrated some ACTUAL bipartisanship.

    I'm only his protective big sister, but still, I'm proud of Jon for knowing columns like this one (and much worse, I know) would be written and still calling 'em like he sees 'em.

    Mary Erpenbach

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ms. Erpenbach,

    >> ...Tuesday's soiree could have celebrated some ACTUAL bipartisanship. <<

    Ah. The no-true-Scotsman argument. Well, you're entitled to your opinion.

    As to the corporate tax "giveaway", I'll give this a try: corporate taxes are just another expense that is paid for by corporate revenues. Revenues come from sales of products and services. If the taxes are higher, then, basically, there have to be more sales to cover them. Often any increase in sales comes from higher prices charged by the corporation to its customers. So that tax line item is paid for by you and me.

    The febrile political climate has produced the notion that raising corporate taxes is justified since corporate profits are earned off the backs of their employees and customers. What's missed is that, to channel money to the government, corporations will cut employment and raise prices in order to survive. So we pay for it twice over if we happen to be the ones let go by the corporation to cover their increased taxes.

    I'm not a corporate shill, believe it or not. I simply can do arithmetic.

    Regards,

    The Town Crank
    Neenah

    ReplyDelete
  5. I find it interesting that you say “no hard feelings, let’s turn a new page and work together” when Walker has NEVER entertained the idea of working together, except with his cronies and millionaires. Proof is in the pudding....not the brats and beer. And as for doing "simple arithmetic," maybe we should start with the fact that nurses, teachers, police officers, welders, fire fighters, and the others blamed for this nonsense did not bankrupt this state. We are tax payers just as much as every other private sector worker in this state (we just aren't compensated in the same way....when broken down to "simple arithmetic" private sector workers still make MUCH MORE money than public sector workers) and to say otherwise is a BOLD faced LIE. We're sick of the misdirection this blame has taken, we are not the reason this happened and should not be made the scapegoats (or have our careers disrespected, despised, and degraded - we put others before ourselves and should be recognized for that)....but someone needs to be when DIVIDE and CONQUER is the ultimate goal. Why do we need to be conquered? And really, to say things like "when you get your ass kicked as hard as the Democrats did last week" is really a bit of an overstatement.....I think it's been proven that this is still a very divided state, because of Imperial Walker.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, annony, where do I start? You "KNOW" that Walker is not now entertaining the idea of working together? And you know this how?

      The saying is "the proof of the pudding is in the eating", not "the proof is in the pudding" (which is nonsense, and so many people say it).

      And, losing five of the six recall elections is NOT an ass-kicking? Since when? Or are you a product of the Madison school district's "success for all" meme?

      Delete
  6. maybe we should start with the fact that nurses, teachers, police officers, welders, fire fighters, and the others blamed for this nonsense did not bankrupt this state. We are tax payers just as much as every other private sector worker in this state (we just aren't compensated in the same way....when broken down to "simple arithmetic" private sector workers still make MUCH MORE money than public sector workers) and to say otherwise is a BOLD faced LIE.

    Yah, all those studies are just lies. And NOBODY else on the face of the Earth 'puts others first.' Nobody. Certainly, everyone disrespected your careers. All the time. It was on billboards: "DISS the PEU Members". I remember that clearly.

    For someone as altruistic as you think you are, you sure as Hell whine a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Heck, I didn't vote for the guy but I'd still go (can I take Pocan's place? I'm free for lunch). What does it hurt to just go hear what he has to say? Both sides need to put hot button issues aside and work on jobs. Plenty of room for bipartisan agreement and cooperation on that. As for Nass, I couldn't agree more.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This stuff is very popular with normal folks, you know, the ones with lives outside of politics. Most people understand things like winning graciously and good sportsmanship.

    Fringe loons such as Anon at 8.45pm and others will, of course, grouse about it, but it is a marvelous thing for Walker to propose.

    By the way for Anon at 2.31pm, it appears that Sprecher will be the beer of choice. Smart move.

    ReplyDelete